Why Do I Keep Rolling My Ankle? What Recurrent Ankle Sprains Really Need
If you've sprained your ankle once, you probably remember the swelling, bruising and awkward limp that followed.
But what if it keeps happening?
Maybe your first ankle sprain was years ago, but the ankle still feels less stable than the other side. Perhaps you repeatedly roll it playing soccer, hiking or running on trails. Or maybe it doesn't hurt much anymore, but you don't completely trust it when jumping, landing or changing direction.
This is something I see frequently in active adults and athletes.
And while an ankle brace can be useful, repeated ankle sprains aren't always solved by simply wearing more support.
The ankle often needs to regain the strength, balance, mobility and ability to react to unpredictable movement that your activity requires.
Why are repeat ankle sprains so common?
An ankle sprain is more than just a temporarily painful ankle.
The most common type is a lateral ankle sprain, which typically occurs when the foot rolls inward and stresses the ligaments on the outside of the ankle.
Pain and swelling may settle relatively quickly, but that doesn't necessarily mean every aspect of ankle function has recovered.
After an ankle sprain, some people continue to experience changes in:
Balance
Strength
Ankle mobility
Joint-position awareness
Confidence in the ankle
Ability to react quickly
Jumping and landing control
If those qualities aren't restored before returning to full activity, the ankle may continue to feel vulnerable.
Research supports this concern. A previous ankle sprain is an important risk factor for another ankle sprain, and clinical guidelines specifically recommend balance and proprioceptive exercise following ankle sprain to help reduce recurrence.
“But my ankle doesn't hurt anymore.”
This is where ankle rehabilitation often stops too early.
You sprain your ankle.
You rest for a while.
The swelling improves.
Walking becomes comfortable.
You return to your sport.
But being able to walk without pain and being ready to sprint, cut, land or react to another player are very different things.
Think about soccer.
Your ankle needs to tolerate:
Accelerating
Decelerating
Cutting
Landing
Being bumped by another player
Uneven foot positions
Rapid changes of direction
The same principle applies to trail running, basketball, volleyball, tennis and many other activities.
If rehabilitation ends once normal walking feels okay, there can be a significant gap between feeling better and being prepared for your sport.
What is chronic ankle instability?
Some people develop ongoing symptoms following one or more ankle sprains, commonly referred to as chronic ankle instability.
You may notice:
Repeated ankle sprains
A feeling that the ankle “gives way”
Lack of confidence on uneven surfaces
Difficulty balancing on the affected leg
Persistent stiffness
Difficulty with jumping or landing
An ankle that simply doesn't feel as reliable as the other side
Not everyone who has sprained an ankle develops chronic instability, but recurrent symptoms are worth addressing rather than accepting as your new normal.
Does ankle strength matter?
Yes—but strengthening the ankle means more than moving a resistance band in four directions.
Those exercises can be useful early in rehabilitation, but your ankle eventually needs to tolerate much greater forces.
For many active people, rehabilitation may progress toward exercises such as:
Calf raises
Both straight-knee and bent-knee calf raises can help develop the calf complex.
Over time, these can progress from double-leg to single-leg variations and eventually to heavier resistance.
Foot and ankle strengthening
Exercises that challenge the muscles controlling the foot and ankle can help improve your ability to maintain and adapt your foot position under load.
Single-leg strength
Split squats, step-ups, lunges and single-leg hinges can help integrate the ankle with the knee and hip rather than treating it as an isolated joint.
The goal isn't simply to make the ankle stronger on a treatment table.
It's to make the entire leg more capable of handling the demands of your activity.
Don't forget balance
Balance training is one of the most consistently supported components of rehabilitation for recurrent ankle sprains.
But balance training should progress too.
Standing on one leg for 30 seconds might be an appropriate starting point. If you're returning to soccer, however, that probably isn't where your rehabilitation should end.
A progression might look something like:
Single-leg balance → reaching tasks → unstable or dynamic balance → single-leg landing → multidirectional movement → reactive sport-specific tasks
The further you progress, the more the exercises begin to resemble the demands your ankle actually faces.
Recent systematic reviews have found that balance training can improve function and dynamic balance in people with chronic ankle instability, while broader exercise programs can also improve strength and functional performance.
What about ankle mobility?
Mobility can matter as well.
One movement I commonly assess following ankle sprain is ankle dorsiflexion—your ability to move your knee forward over your foot while keeping your heel down.
Limited dorsiflexion can affect movements such as:
Squatting
Lunging
Running
Landing
Going downstairs
That doesn't mean everyone who has sprained an ankle needs aggressive mobility work.
The first question is whether a meaningful restriction is actually present.
If it is, targeted mobility work may form one part of the rehabilitation program.
When should jumping be added?
If your goal involves running or sport, eventually.
Walking and traditional strength exercises don't fully prepare the ankle for the rapid forces involved in running, jumping and changing direction.
Once appropriate, rehabilitation can progress toward:
Pogo jumps
Single-leg hops
Lateral hops
Skater bounds
Forward hops
Jump-and-stick landings
Repeated hopping
Multidirectional jumping
From there, drills can become faster and less predictable.
For a soccer player, for example, the next stage might include acceleration, deceleration, cutting, reactive change-of-direction drills and eventually ball work.
This progression is important because sport isn't predictable.
Your ankle needs to do more than perform well when you know exactly what's coming next.
Do you need an ankle brace?
Sometimes.
Bracing and taping can be useful after ankle sprain, particularly for people returning to activities with a higher risk of reinjury.
Evidence-based clinical guidelines support bracing as one strategy for reducing recurrent ankle sprains.
But a brace and rehabilitation don't have to be an either/or decision.
You may use external support while simultaneously rebuilding strength, balance and confidence.
Over time, whether you continue using a brace depends on your injury history, sport, symptoms, preferences and how the ankle is functioning.
When are you ready to return to sport?
There isn't one exercise or test that can guarantee you're ready.
Instead, I want to know how the ankle performs across several areas.
Can you:
Move through the range of motion your sport requires?
Produce good calf and lower-leg strength?
Balance confidently on one leg?
Hop and land?
Move laterally?
Accelerate and decelerate?
Change direction?
React to an unpredictable movement?
Complete progressively harder practices without a significant increase in pain or swelling?
Just as importantly:
Do you trust the ankle again?
Physical recovery and confidence both matter when returning to sport.
What if you sprained your ankle years ago?
It's not necessarily too late to work on it.
If your ankle continues to feel unstable, stiff or weaker than the other side, rehabilitation can still address the deficits that remain.
You don't need to wait for another major sprain before working on it.
In fact, between injuries can be an excellent time to build strength and capacity because you're not dealing with the same level of acute pain and swelling.
The takeaway
If you keep rolling the same ankle, don't assume you simply have “bad ankles.”
Your ankle may need more than rest.
A comprehensive rehabilitation program can address:
Mobility where needed
Foot and ankle strength
Calf strength
Balance and proprioception
Single-leg control
Jumping and landing
Change of direction
Sport-specific demands
The goal isn't just to get the pain to settle.
The goal is to prepare your ankle for what you actually want it to do.
If you're dealing with recurrent ankle sprains or an ankle that still doesn't feel trustworthy, an Athletic Therapy assessment in Victoria, BC can help identify what hasn't fully recovered and build a progressive plan around your sport and goals.
At Proactive Therapy, rehabilitation is designed to bridge the gap between recovering from an injury and confidently returning to running, soccer, hiking, strength training and the activities you enjoy.
This article is for general educational purposes and isn't a substitute for an individualized assessment or medical care.
Helpful Links
